Base oils are the foundation of every lubricant. But not all base oils are created equal. Among the most debated are Group III and Group IV base stocks. Both are used in so-called “synthetic” motor oils, yet they differ drastically in origin, chemistry, and performance.
Understanding these differences is key to cutting through marketing claims and choosing the right oil for your application.
Group III base oils are severely hydrocracked petroleum oils. Though derived from crude oil, they undergo intense processing:
The result is a very pure oil with:
These stats qualify it for the Group III classification under API standards. Despite its petroleum origin, Group III oil can legally be marketed as synthetic in North America.
Group III+ refers to ultra-high VI versions of these oils, further refined for better performance and often used in premium formulations.
Group IV base oils are polyalphaolefins (PAOs). Unlike Group III, they are chemically synthesized rather than refined from crude oil. PAOs are made by polymerizing alpha-olefin molecules, resulting in a uniform molecular structure.
Key advantages of PAOs:
PAOs are the true engineered synthetics, built molecule by molecule for consistent performance. They form the core of most high-end synthetic formulations and are often blended with Group V esters for added solvency.
While both can meet performance specs like API SP or ACEA C3, PAOs often exceed them in extreme environments.
In 1999, Castrol challenged the definition of “synthetic” in a dispute with Mobil. Castrol argued that their hydrocracked Group III oil was synthetic. Mobil disagreed, claiming only chemically engineered PAOs should qualify.
The National Advertising Division (NAD) sided with Castrol, setting a precedent: Group III oils can be marketed as synthetic. Mobil eventually followed suit and reformulated Mobil 1 with Group III components.
This ruling blurred the lines between real synthetic oils and highly refined mineral oils, confusing consumers to this day. It also led to the rise of the phrase “real synthetic” among oil enthusiasts to distinguish PAO-based products.
One of the biggest performance differences between Group III and IV comes down to molecular uniformity.
Not at all. Group III oils are highly refined and offer excellent performance for most drivers. They meet or exceed the demands of modern engines, including turbocharged and direct injection platforms.
They are also more affordable and widely available. For daily drivers, commuter vehicles, and even light-duty trucks, Group III synthetics often provide more than enough protection.
The problem lies in transparency. Most consumers don’t realize that many “full synthetics” at retail are actually Group III blends. Brands rarely disclose base oil groups unless they’re using PAO and esters as a premium differentiator.
PAO-based synthetics shine in conditions where performance matters most:
They also maintain viscosity better over time, resist sludge formation, and improve reliability in turbochargers and variable valve timing systems.
Unfortunately, base oil groups are rarely disclosed on the bottle. To figure it out:
PAO-based oils tend to be sold via specialty channels or premium product lines. Mass-market synthetics are nearly all Group III.
Group III oils are highly refined mineral oils; Group IV (PAO) oils are chemically synthesized. PAOs offer better performance in extreme conditions.
Yes. PAO (Group IV) is a true synthetic oil made from uniform, lab-created molecules.
No. Many retail “full synthetics” are made with Group III base oils due to cost.
No. Group III oils are high quality and meet modern specifications, but they are not chemically synthetic.
You usually can’t from the label. Some manufacturers disclose it, but many don’t. Look for technical data sheets (TDS) or contact the company.
Generally yes, especially under stress or extended drains. Its superior oxidation resistance means it breaks down slower.
Cost, availability, and consumer perception. Group III oils are cheaper to make and still meet certifications. Most buyers don’t know the difference.
No. Group III+ has improved properties over standard Group III but still isn’t chemically synthetic. It’s a high-end mineral oil, not a PAO.
Yes. Many premium formulations are blended with both, balancing cost and performance.
Powered by LubeGuide
Built to help you make informed choices about lubricants, maintenance, and vehicle performance. No hype. Just facts.